"I never said you weren't"

They're diverting from the topic, but...

"Different worlds with different variations on the same theme, that makes some sense." He's already seen Erin and come to terms with her world's broken Mask, so this isn't quite the jarring thought it could be "I suppose I may as well tell you, I'm not entirely human myself."

Gilbert isn't going to be happy, but what can you do.